[Street] [Ob-media] [Ideas] [Occupybostonoutreach] proposal to table GA until Friday (in lieu of community forum on immediate problems)
Deborah Sirotkin Butler
amberpaw at gmail.com
Wed Dec 14 12:41:37 EST 2011
Thank you,Greg. Concurrently holding both kinds of meetings is both healthy
and proactive. Deb on droid
On Dec 14, 2011 12:11 PM, "Gregory Murphy" <gsjmurphy at gmail.com> wrote:
> they are both happening
>
> GA at Emmanuel Church, 15 Newbury Street, on Thursday @ 7:00 PM
>
> Community dialogue meeting Friday night at St. Paul's , I think at 6:00
>
>
> Please know that Facilitation, soon, will be presenting a proposal for a
> weekly Community Gathering event.
>
>
> Greg
>
>
>
> On Wed, Dec 14, 2011 at 12:03 PM, Martin <m2 at occupyboston.org> wrote:
>
>> **
>> I strongly support both Eli's amendments and the issues Katie raised.
>>
>> Also point of information Rachel is planning another key forum on just
>> this topic on Saturday.
>>
>> This does bring up the dangers of only using community gatherings like GA
>> as strictly governing body's who only make oceans of announcements and
>> decisions making and have zero space for community dialogue. such an
>> idiotic system is called the united states congress. and we have all seen
>> how well that has worked for our nation.
>>
>> lets do both: Thursday GA AND Friday forum. or switch them. *PLEASE!*
>>
>> cheers
>>
>> martin
>>
>>
>> On 12/14/11 11:39 AM, Ben Janos wrote:
>>
>> +1 to Eli.
>>
>> While I agree that there are serious issues we need to deal with as a
>> community, we don't need to cancel GA Thursday to do it. I strongly support
>> the friendly ammendment to have the forum on Friday, while keeping
>> Thursday's GA time and place the same as was decided at yesterday's GA.
>>
>> in solidarity
>> Ben
>>
>> On Wed, Dec 14, 2011 at 10:34 AM, Elias Feghali <efeghali at gmail.com>wrote:
>>
>>> Katie,
>>>
>>> I strongly agree with your analysis of our current situation. I
>>> appreciate you articulating them so succinctly and with such vision.
>>>
>>> I would like to amend your proposal to cancel GA, by moving that we
>>> continue with GA on Thursday at Emmanuel from 7-11, but also hold the forum
>>> on Friday at St. Paul's from 6-830 to have a focused discussion on finding
>>> a community solution to our most pressing problems. There is hardly enough
>>> consensus that cancelling GA is the right thing to do, and I fear it might
>>> cause tension and anxiety for the group.
>>>
>>> I would also urge the facilitation group to take your stated concerns
>>> into serious consideration. I trust the group to figure out how can we
>>> adjust the process to meet our needs at the moment. One suggestion I have
>>> is to require all announcements by noon the day of a GA, to be compiled,
>>> and printed out for distribution at GA -- saving us over an hour for time
>>> to discuss proposals and perhaps even create space to have strategy focused
>>> discussions.
>>>
>>> Thanks again Katie,
>>> Eli
>>>
>>> On Wed, Dec 14, 2011 at 10:08 AM, Elizabeth Holmes <sherlock at mit.edu>wrote:
>>>
>>>> Thank you Katie,
>>>>
>>>> I wanted to speak to the houseless issue. I'm in OWS right now
>>>> trying to figure out how they are housing everyone. Thus far, I've seen a
>>>> huge involvement of churches & religious communities. OWS has the support
>>>> of 14,000 religious leaders of an upcoming action that will be HUGELY
>>>> valuable for us.
>>>>
>>>> I'm begging for people to start plugging more into the religious
>>>> community in Boston. I'm going to reach out to Our Lady of Perpetual
>>>> Health in Roxbury Crossing as I used to intern there. I highly recommend
>>>> the same action of others to religious connections they have. Please do
>>>> keep medics & safety/mediation in the loop as the two working groups should
>>>> be prepared to provide support at these locations.
>>>>
>>>> See y'all soon! I'll have a longer response when I sit down to a
>>>> laptop.
>>>>
>>>> Solidarity,
>>>>
>>>> Eli
>>>> Occupy Boston / Wall Street
>>>> www.elizabethannholmes.com
>>>> @occupymom
>>>>
>>>> On Dec 14, 2011, at 1:35 AM, Katie Gradowski <katie.gradowski at gmail.com>
>>>> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> Hey all,
>>>>
>>>> I'm forwarding this email widely because it seems pressing. The past
>>>> two GAs following eviction have felt very out of place -- I feel like we,
>>>> as a community, have not yet dealt with the eviction from Dewey Square,
>>>> which has resulted in a creeping sense of sprawl and dysfunction. This
>>>> email is a tentative call for a reset!
>>>>
>>>> *A brief overview of my concerns: *
>>>>
>>>> Over the past two days, we have seen hours worth of working group
>>>> announcements, in many cases for working groups whose purpose and identity
>>>> has irrevocably shifted. We have seen "message" proposals, even as we
>>>> have houseless occupiers who have gone days without a place to stay. We
>>>> have had a proliferation of hastily planned actions, with no thought or
>>>> coordination of how we, as a community, want to respond to eviction, or of
>>>> coordinated actions between working groups in response to eviction from
>>>> Dewey Square. Reports so far on tonight's GA (contentious issues of
>>>> storage, personal attacks, a proposal to send homeless occupiers to DC?)
>>>> suggests that things are not getting better.
>>>>
>>>> While this is all happening, there are pressing issues that have not
>>>> yet been resolved. I feel deeply uncomfortable moving forward in any
>>>> sense until we can take time, as a group, can resolve the question of space
>>>> and housing. I would like to propose tabling Thursday's GA, and in its
>>>> place scheduling an open community forum this Friday, at St. Paul's
>>>> Cathedral, from 6-8:30 p.m. to find immediate, community-wide solutions to
>>>> the following three concerns:
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> ******************************************************************************************************************************************
>>>>
>>>> IMMEDIATE ISSUES (to be resolved in the next few days)
>>>>
>>>> *1) Permanent space for GA + reassessment of working groups *---
>>>> Without a site, we have sprawl on all sides. Working groups that no
>>>> longer have space, GAs are tentatively planned, lots of options on the
>>>> table for sites but no solid choices, defunct groups consolidating with
>>>> other groups. We need to sit down and map out the new terrain. What is
>>>> the new "site" for OB, in the absence of Dewey Square? (don't outsource
>>>> this to a working group! let's solve it together) Do we want a central
>>>> space for everything or several diffuse spaces? Do we want roving GAs in
>>>> JP, Chinatown, Dorchester, and elsewhere? (and is it important for Gas and
>>>> working groups to be in the same space?) Do we want to rent or borrow?
>>>> Do we want a food truck and a caravan of tiny houses? And if so, how do
>>>> we make that happen?
>>>>
>>>> *Between now and Friday, I propose that *everyone* who has an idea or
>>>> plan about permanent space take this week (facilitation, logistics,
>>>> outreach, Eric, Greg, Brian, myself) write it up as a proposal, and bring
>>>> it with actionable items to Friday's community forum*. In line with
>>>> that, I propose that as many working groups as possible check in with
>>>> updated information about where you are meeting and how you are situated,
>>>> post-eviction. *This is a top priority at the moment*. Without a
>>>> space to assemble and a concrete proposal for what space we want to
>>>> inhabit, post-Dewey, we will not be able to settle long enough to
>>>> accomplish anything of substance. We'll split up, peter out, start
>>>> meeting separately, stop checking in, and that will be the end of Occupy
>>>> Boston.
>>>>
>>>> *2) Long term winter solution for houseless occupiers * -- At the
>>>> moment, we have up to 10 people remaining who are active occupiers who need
>>>> a place to stay. At least 4 are couples and cannot go into the shelter
>>>> system. *We cannot rely on occupiers who have stepped up to offer
>>>> short-term housing as a long-term solution to this issue. * Those of
>>>> us who have offered space are already stretched thin and are trying hard to
>>>> fill in the gaps. Many of these people have stuck it out after eviction,
>>>> helping to coordinate space logistics and participating in GAs and working
>>>> groups, in spite of the very real possibility of spending the night in a
>>>> bus station.The occupiers who remain are part of our community, and we need
>>>> a community solution to this issue.
>>>>
>>>> *We need an immediate solution to the question fo where they will be
>>>> housed. * Possible short term solutions: rotating couch space, church
>>>> space, others? long-term solution: outreach to places that will allow us
>>>> to pitch tents (not a good option over winter)? large indoor spaces with
>>>> housing? renting an apartment for houseless occupiers over winter?
>>>> Sending people to other occupations is not an option -- nor is farming this
>>>> out to a working group or a dedicated set of individuals. If we are truly
>>>> a community, we need a community solution to this issue. Most of these
>>>> people have arrangements that are expiring by the end of the week. This
>>>> issue must be dealt with, before any broader questions of message and
>>>> direction are considered.
>>>>
>>>> *3) OB actions this week, next week, and moving forward. * I had a
>>>> conversation with some folks in media a few days ago about message, and
>>>> someone remarked (quite rightly) that the way we make statements now is not
>>>> with words, but with actions. There are a number of very exciting actions
>>>> coming out of the community organization meetings, as well as a
>>>> proliferation of exciting, small-scale actions (tiny tents, anyone?) that
>>>> are in progress. Let's coordinate TOGETHER, plan across working groups,
>>>> and approach these actions in a really intentional way!
>>>>
>>>> This week has seen more sprawl than usual, with a proliferation of
>>>> actions, many reactionary, quickly planned with little coordination or
>>>> thought of execution. Autonomous action is fine, but too easily becomes an
>>>> excuse to throw things together at the last minute -- let's NOT use GA
>>>> announcements as a place to plan actions in the hopes that people will just
>>>> show up -- let's actually sit down and plan them together! *There
>>>> are two meetings taking place this weekend -- an OB action summit (Sunday
>>>> at 1) and a community-wide spokescouncil meeting to plan for a mass day of
>>>> action sometime in January or February.* Let's prioritize these
>>>> meetings, and use that space as a jumping-off point for a larger discussion
>>>> of what we, as a community, want to prioritize going forward.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> *********************************************************************************************************
>>>>
>>>> WIDER POST-EVICTION THOUGHTS - on GA, facilitation, and the need for
>>>> open community spaces
>>>>
>>>> (this is less urgent - feel free to skip it if you like -- they deal
>>>> with my broader concerns about GA, and how we can move forward as a
>>>> community in the wake of eviction from Dewey Square
>>>>
>>>> *Reclaiming GAs as a public space* -- the past two GAs have felt very
>>>> closed at a time when they need to be radically open -- they have carried
>>>> on with "business as usual," instead of reclaiming GAs as an open forum
>>>> (which they initially were). In the wake of eviction, we need SOME spaces
>>>> for "loose" facilitation, for town hall stye forum, similar to what we had
>>>> in the beginning ---> perhaps reviving the PROPOSAL FOR COMMUNITY NIGHTS?
>>>> how to deal with the sprawl of announcements?? replacing WG
>>>> announcements with print copies to circulate -- info desk at GA? -- all of
>>>> these and more. now, more than ever, we need to make it a radically open
>>>> space, and be proactive about inviting new people in
>>>>
>>>> In the days and weeks leading up to eviction, many people remarked
>>>> privately to me that they felt OB becoming a closed community, with people
>>>> onsite "taking care of their own," and offsite working groups operating in
>>>> total isolation of each other. Post-eviction, we have followed "business
>>>> as usual" -- continuing meetings, highly procedural GAs, prioritizing an
>>>> hour of working group announcements, and dragging on for hours.
>>>>
>>>> We need to respond to GA specifically -- but we also need to actively
>>>> create spaces for people to meet and socialize, building in time for social
>>>> events, community forums (like the one I'm proposing right now),
>>>> discussion meetings, teach-ins, and debate -- planning them in advance and
>>>> publicizing them widely, so that people outside the mailing lists will know
>>>> about them and can come. In line with this, we need to actively make use
>>>> of the website, wiki, facebook, and twitter make sure we are publicizing
>>>> our events, keeping people up to date, and coordinating within Occupy
>>>> Boston in order to get the word out in a timely manner.
>>>>
>>>> *Taking care of our own*. When occupied, Dewey Square was in a
>>>> constant state of crisis. It was impossible to respond, react, or slow
>>>> down long enough to deal with the myriad issues -- chief among them, the
>>>> marginalization of houseless occupiers and people of color. Their needs
>>>> need to be addressed and put front and center in any discussion of how we
>>>> as a community move forward as a community (whether they be clothing,
>>>> shelter, living assistance, a place to take showers, etc)
>>>>
>>>> *Prioritizing people over process:* David made a proposal at
>>>> Saturday's facilitation meeting to go back to loose process and allow
>>>> people to speak openly at the post-eviction GA. This didn't happen, and
>>>> to date, no space for this kind of open conversation has been made.
>>>> Post-eviction, we need to reintroduce a sense of radical openness to GA,
>>>> even if it slows things down or breaks process. *We need spaces for
>>>> loose facilitation, even at the expense of efficiency, both to take into
>>>> account (and deal with) our radically changed circumstances, and to make
>>>> space for new people to have a place in the dialogue.* Strong
>>>> facilitation is comforting to some and profoundly alienating to others --
>>>> at this juncture, I feel pretty strongly that we need spaces for both
>>>> strong facilitation and open, spontaneous dialogue -- and that if this
>>>> isn't currently happening in GA, we need to make it so.
>>>>
>>>> *Collaboration across working groups. * For anyone who was at last
>>>> night's community orgs meeting, it was an amazing example of coordination
>>>> across groups -- we had four solid proposals on the table for upcoming
>>>> actions (from January through March) and left with actionable items on each
>>>> one. For the first time in the history of that meeting, there were
>>>> representatives from media,outreach, facilitation, and community
>>>> organizations from across Boston. At the facilitation meeting last
>>>> Saturday,likewise, there were representatives from almost all of the major
>>>> working groups. It felt amazing, to see and begin to plan large-scale
>>>> collaborative actions as a group, with thoughtful, intentional buy-in from
>>>> everyone in the room.
>>>>
>>>> Too often, we farm out difficult decisions to working groups or create
>>>> new ones on the spot, rather than do the workto have these conversations.
>>>> We need to create spaces where we can collaborate TOGETHER to solve
>>>> pressing issues across working groups, marshal our existing resources and
>>>> work together, across working groups, to plan actions, solutions,
>>>> discussions, and next steps. More conversations like this = more work
>>>> that can immediately get done (and can get done together!), which is what's
>>>> going to keep us together in the long run.
>>>>
>>>> *********************************************************************************************************************************
>>>>
>>>> Everything that's outlined above is hard. We need to be thoughtful,
>>>> intentional, and have the courage to take things slowly rather than rush to
>>>> keep up with press coverage and the post-eviction spotlight. We also need
>>>> to try, as best we can, not to trash each other by email as we work through
>>>> these difficult issues.
>>>>
>>>> Without a space -- and in particular, without concrete accommodations
>>>> made for our most marginalized members -- I feel it will be very hard to
>>>> move forward on any of the rest of it in a meaningful way. I propose that
>>>> we start this conversation Friday at 6 p.m. at St. Paul's Cathedral.
>>>>
>>>> Those are my thoughts! Please let me know yours.
>>>>
>>>> All best,
>>>>
>>>> Katie
>>>>
>>>>
>>>
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Occupybostonoutreach mailing list
>>>
>>> Post: Occupybostonoutreach at lists.occupyboston.org
>>> List info:
>>> https://lists.mayfirst.org/mailman/listinfo/occupybostonoutreach
>>>
>>> To Unsubscribe
>>> Send email to:
>>> Occupybostonoutreach-unsubscribe at lists.occupyboston.org
>>> Or visit:
>>> https://lists.mayfirst.org/mailman/options/occupybostonoutreach/occupyprospecthill%40gmail.com
>>>
>>> You are subscribed as: occupyprospecthill at gmail.com
>>>
>>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Occupybostonoutreach mailing list
>>
>> Post: Occupybostonoutreach at lists.occupyboston.org
>> List info: https://lists.mayfirst.org/mailman/listinfo/occupybostonoutreach
>>
>> To Unsubscribe
>> Send email to: Occupybostonoutreach-unsubscribe at lists.occupyboston.org
>>
>> Or visit: https://lists.mayfirst.org/mailman/options/occupybostonoutreach/m2%40occupyboston.org
>>
>> You are subscribed as: m2 at occupyboston.org
>>
>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Ideas mailing list
>>
>> Post: Ideas at lists.occupyboston.org
>> List info: https://lists.mayfirst.org/mailman/listinfo/ideas
>>
>> To Unsubscribe
>> Send email to: Ideas-unsubscribe at lists.occupyboston.org
>> Or visit:
>> https://lists.mayfirst.org/mailman/options/ideas/gsjmurphy%40gmail.com
>>
>> You are subscribed as: gsjmurphy at gmail.com
>>
>>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Ob-media mailing list
>
> Post: Ob-media at lists.occupyboston.org
> List info: https://lists.mayfirst.org/mailman/listinfo/ob-media
>
> To Unsubscribe
> Send email to: Ob-media-unsubscribe at lists.occupyboston.org
> Or visit:
> https://lists.mayfirst.org/mailman/options/ob-media/amberpaw%40gmail.com
>
> You are subscribed as: amberpaw at gmail.com
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.mayfirst.org/mailman/private/street/attachments/20111214/962dd0c6/attachment-0001.htm>
More information about the Street
mailing list